Follow Whitehill Online

whitehillonlinefollowontwitter whitehillonlineonfacebook

Kidsgrove Weather

Whitehill Online Poll

Will the recent way NBC has handled the travellers situation impact who you vote for in future council elections?

Yes I will vote for a different party / councillor than our current lot in Kidsgrove - 91.8%
No I will vote for the party / councillor who represent Kidsgrove now. - 8.2%

Kidsgrove Councillor Margaret Astle Questions Democracy

kidsgrove town council astleKidsgrove and Newcastle Borough Council Margaret Astle appears once again to question the role of democracy in her online postings. It had been reported that Kidsgrove and Newcastle Borough Councillor Margaret Astles online website was reporting to be “suspended”, however now back online we have been made aware of some interesting comments by the Kidsgrove Councillor.

It all centres on the right of the electorate to call an election when an elected member leaves office. This is a given right and as long as 10 residents ask for an election, one has to be held. When former UKIP Kidsgrove Councillor Mathew Banner stepped down from representing the Talke Ward this left Kidsgrove Council requiring a new member.

Kidsgrove Town Council has seen a high number of councillors leave Kidsgrove Town Council, with all previous slots being filled by the council “co-oping” members to the council. It has been interesting to note how prior to this it was nearly all Labour representatives being co-opted on to Kidsgrove Town Council. This action clearly would not impress other political parties who clearly felt that the Labour leadership were playing politics at Kidsgrove Town Council.

Margaret Astle in her online postings appears to be criticizing the democratic system which exists. She states “It now appears that the by-election has been called by former UKIP councillor Matthew Banner” … “Is this an error or sheer malice?” She then goes on further to name the person who has handed in the electoral request form into Newcastle Borough Council “I have also made inquiries at Newcastle borough council and I have been reliably informed that a male with the name of Alex Wright personally handed in the documentation containing the necessary signatures in order to call the Talke by-election.” “I must admit that I am astounded by this form of behaviour!”

I’m sure that many Kidsgrove residents are also astounded by this behaviour from Margaret Astle. It is also quite worrying that Newcastle Borough Council will disclose such information about residents for a councillors to public online.

This isn’t the first time that Margaret Astle has made such an opposition to the democratic right of the Kidsgrove electorate. In 2010 she was making similar claims regarding the calling of an election in Newchapel.


Kidsgrove and Newcastle Councillor Margaret Astle appears to get confused as to the responsibly of Newcastle Borough Council and Kidsgrove Town Council, when suggesting other alternative spends for the cost of any election. She goes on to state “Kidsgrove and Talke have been starved of funding for over three years and both area’s are full of pot holes,  the roads are in a state of disrepair.  We have weeds growing out of the blocked gullies and on the edges of the broken kerb stones.   Inadequate street lighting needs to be replaced…”. All of this is not the responsibility of the above councils and comes out of a totally separate budget. Many Kidsgrove residents have recently been commenting on how impressed they have been with the standard of the roads in Kidsgrove following massive investment from Staffordshire County Council.

There is one interesting final remark in Margaret Astle’s posting “Kidsgrove town council could have easily co-opted an independent candidate…”. Interesting comment given that co-opting is meant to involve an interview process and no one would have had the chance to apply.

In the end no election was held in Talke as only one candidate stood for election. Sylvia Dymond, 52 from Church Street in Talke was elected to Kidsgrove Town Councillor as an independent.

Add comment

Security code


0 #6 Molly 2012-11-04 16:01
At least Aarle is giving the Lib Dems a resting targeting another party who maybe a danger to her Party.
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #5 Jess 2012-11-04 14:25
Surely Matthew Banner could hand in the papers on behalf of UKIP but they have to be signed by so many electorate. I am surprised that she asked for details from NBC. It would be interesting to find out who handed in or completed notices calling by elections in the past.

What I would like to see on her web site is what she is doing for Kidsgrove and local organisations rather than her constant moaning.
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #4 Jess 2012-11-04 14:09
You can tell that county elections and the Police Commissioner elections are looming. Labour only criticise the opposition and they get elected. Cant people see through their devious tactics?
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #3 Julie 2012-11-03 20:32
The real issue here is the one about NBC handing out such info for a councillor to publish online. I would have hoped that sort of information would be private.
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #2 Sarah Bayles 2012-11-03 11:47
The last part is the best.

She says that they could appoint an independent easily. Who has joined the council an independent.

How independent is she? Why didn't Labour fight this election like they have elsewhere. Where are the other parties as well?
Quote | Report to administrator
0 #1 Kyle 2012-11-03 11:39
How come NBC hand out someone's details like that? Is that electoral policy that you have to publiclally share with Councillors who has called for an election? Why not go one step further and publish everyone's voting paterns?

Also have Labour locally never called an election? I don't know the answer to this but I would hope it isn't a case of people in glass houses.

Why do Labour allow her and her family to represent Kidsgrove? I'm a Labour voter but I never put my x against her or her family members names.
Quote | Report to administrator